OOAK Table Tennis Forum
http://ooakforum.com/

Q & A about Plastic balls - by ITTF's Torsten Küneth
http://ooakforum.com/viewtopic.php?f=69&t=26354
Page 14 of 14

Author:  Torsten [ 19 Jun 2017, 07:38 ]
Post subject:  Re: Q & A about Plastic balls - by ITTF's Torsten Küneth

As to the two last postings above: Not quite sure which answer exceeding those on pages 5 and 16 of my Q&A presentation is expected, so assumed these questions were actually already handeled. If, however, I missed something technical to answer, please remind me and I will do.

Author:  Retriever [ 19 Jun 2017, 12:20 ]
Post subject:  Re: Q & A about Plastic balls - by ITTF's Torsten Küneth

Hi Torsten,

If a player is found to be breaking the rules, or even if there is a number of strikes policy for a particular breaking of the rules, it is public.

We amateur players are asking if a ball or any other manufacturer is found breaking the rules if their sanctioning is public in the same way, and if not, make it so.

For example there are rules regarding characteristics of balls. We players can count how many balls in a box are simply not round for example, and see in tournaments the horrible longevity of the DHS 40+ balls that have been used for another example, necessitating a clarification to umpires of what is to occur if a ball breaks in the middle of a rally, and the practice of issuing new balls every so many games.

It seems that no-one is accountable for the situation that there has been with the plastic balls, although it does seem to be getting better (the situation, not the accountability).

Author:  Torsten [ 19 Jun 2017, 17:12 ]
Post subject:  Re: Q & A about Plastic balls - by ITTF's Torsten Küneth

First I am glad to hear, again, that it is now getting better. In my view, one of the reasons for this is that accountability for quality deficiencies clearly lies with the manufacturers. And that they were aware of this and did not push it away. When the ITTF random testing of balls produced some failures, we could observe the information flow between the supplier affected and (if not OEM) his manufacturer. It could clearly be seen that this led to the improvements in design (rather than to denying responsibilities) which is now reflected in balls approved 2016 or later. Of course, those will also be randomly tested.

As to a complete disclosure of failed quality checks, I can only report that I do not see any tendency in ITTF's governing bodys to change this policy.

Author:  Retriever [ 20 Jun 2017, 07:18 ]
Post subject:  Re: Q & A about Plastic balls - by ITTF's Torsten Küneth

Thank you yet again Torsten for explaining things as much as you are allowed.

Author:  d1244 [ 03 Jul 2017, 06:12 ]
Post subject:  Re: Q & A about Plastic balls - by ITTF's Torsten Küneth

I have heard rumours, that most of the 40+ balls already approved, may be ceased to be approved in the nearest future (because allegedly they are not 100% non-celluoid). This is supposed to have something to do with the intro of balls like DHS D40+. Is it true?

Author:  Torsten [ 06 Jul 2017, 06:46 ]
Post subject:  Re: Q & A about Plastic balls - by ITTF's Torsten Küneth

That is fully up to the manufacturers. We do not have indication by them that they plan to stop the approval of the 1st generation non-cell balls very shortly, but in the mid-term future we expect this to happen for economic reasons: If they feel they now have put an improved ball to the market, which may also be produced at lower cost due to more sophisticated material, then why should they continue forever with the older one.

The chemical argument I cannot confirm. Our own analysis (ca. 2 years ago with the 1st generation balls) does not indicate that the balls contain residuals of celluloid.

Author:  d1244 [ 06 Jul 2017, 06:59 ]
Post subject:  Re: Q & A about Plastic balls - by ITTF's Torsten Küneth

Thanks. Actually, I haven't made myself clear - by approval I meant ITTF approval and I was wondering whether ITTF is planning to remove most of the poly balls from the ITTF approved balls list (because of the introduction of these 'new' gen balls like DHS D40+).

But judging from your post - these are just rumours, am I right?

Author:  GMan4911 [ 06 Jul 2017, 07:58 ]
Post subject:  Re: Q & A about Plastic balls - by ITTF's Torsten Küneth

d1244 wrote:
Thanks. Actually, I haven't made myself clear - by approval I meant ITTF approval and I was wondering whether ITTF is planning to remove most of the poly balls from the ITTF approved balls list (because of the introduction of these 'new' gen balls like DHS D40+).

But judging from your post - these are just rumours, am I right?

The way it works is, as long as the balls meet the required specs AND the manufacturer renews the fee to have it certified, then it will remain on the approved list. If either condition fails, the ball is removed from the approved list.

Author:  Torsten [ 07 Jul 2017, 07:10 ]
Post subject:  Re: Q & A about Plastic balls - by ITTF's Torsten Küneth

Yes, GMan4911 is 100% correct.
And if a ball continues to meet the specs, this is tested randomly by "mystery shopping", i.e. we buy them from retail without any prior announcement and send them to the lab.

So, yes, it would just be a rumour that we (ITTF) are planning to remove approvals systematically.

Author:  mynamenotbob [ 07 Jul 2017, 07:34 ]
Post subject:  Re: Q & A about Plastic balls - by ITTF's Torsten Küneth

Torsten wrote:
Yes, GMan4911 is 100% correct.
And if a ball continues to meet the specs, this is tested randomly by "mystery shopping", i.e. we buy them from retail without any prior announcement and send them to the lab.

So, yes, it would just be a rumour that we (ITTF) are planning to remove approvals systematically.

Any news regarding orange balls?

Author:  Torsten [ 11 Jul 2017, 00:52 ]
Post subject:  Re: Q & A about Plastic balls - by ITTF's Torsten Küneth

Sorry to keep you waiting for three days just to tell you that the answer is Nope. :(
Which does not change our expectation that they will start in early 2018.

Author:  Debater [ 27 Jul 2017, 17:43 ]
Post subject:  Re: Q & A about Plastic balls - by ITTF's Torsten Küneth

Hi Torsten, the contact point of the ITTF for balls is now showing as

Vicky Eleftheriade
Equipment Manager
e-mail: equipment@ittfmail.co

I'm sure it used to be you. Have you moved postion within the Equipment Committee?

Author:  Torsten [ 29 Jul 2017, 04:49 ]
Post subject:  Re: Q & A about Plastic balls - by ITTF's Torsten Küneth

Debater wrote:
Hi Torsten, the contact point of the ITTF for balls is now showing as

Vicky Eleftheriade
Equipment Manager
e-mail: equipment@ittfmail.co

I'm sure it used to be you. Have you moved postion within the Equipment Committee?


No, everything stays the same. Vicky is the professional staff (which I do mean in terms of being paid and in terms of the quality of her work) in charge of equipment in the ITTF office. She has been covering this position -amongst other duties- for the last years. She is handling, for example, all approval processes, daily communication with manufacturers and suppliers, etc.

She is not a member of the Equipment Committee, as I and 13 other people are. Committee Member is not a job position, it's a volunteer's position of being a, say, field expert or advisor or analyst, etc.

Page 14 of 14 All times are UTC + 9:30 hours
Powered by phpBB® Forum Software © phpBB Group
http://www.phpbb.com/